20 Comments
User's avatar
RIcardo Munsel's avatar

Alex, how you are able to connect persons, places, historical events so clearly and so beautifully, I stay amazed. Thank you for this beautiful essay.

Expand full comment
Alexander Verbeek's avatar

Thank you, Ricardo.

Expand full comment
anne's avatar

Oh, Alex, this is one of your best posts yet! So many references to draw from in these dark days (esp. today). I will “adopt” all of your references, but add one that this time in January is especially meaningful to me as a musician: 27January, 1756 is Mozart’s birthday in Salzburg. I’ve celebrated it every year since I was a child, but this year listening to his symphonies and piano concerti brings light into my life. I’m hoping it will last to give me strength and some comfort for the next month (at the very least)! If that doesn’t do it, I’ll re-read

your beautiful post. 😊

Expand full comment
Alexander Verbeek's avatar

Thank you, Anne, that is so nice to hear. I remember Mozart’s house in Salzburg; so good to celebrate his birthday. Yes to celebrating art even more these days. Oh and in the years that I lived in Vienna, I passed the Mozart statue several times a day.

Expand full comment
rena's avatar

"Creativity emerges not despite darkness but because of it - as witness, as protest, as hope."

Truth. Thank you for this inspiring piece.

Expand full comment
Judith L Hubbard's avatar

Perfect 😘

Expand full comment
Amanda Royal's avatar

I love this post so much. I've spent a lot of time researching Gernika. Franco concocted the lie that the Basques perpetrated this on themselves (because that's what fascists do, create outlandish lies), and even though Germany has apologized for it several times (the planes were the Luftwaffe), Spain has never admitted fault.

Expand full comment
Alexander Verbeek's avatar

Fascists never apologize. Like white swans, this remains true until its debunked by Trump apologizing for separating children from their parents at the border, by Trump apologizing for lying more than 30,000 times while in office (as counted by the WP), by apologizing for … etc. Oh, and while we’re at it, fascists don’t smile unless it’s about other peoples misery, there is no humor, and no art reaches above the level of the Village People; art deco sculptures are sacrificed to a sledgehammer.

Expand full comment
Leslie Rasmussen's avatar

A beautiful heart felt essay, thank you.

Expand full comment
Sharon Boyd's avatar

As billionaire tech giants jostled for the best seats in the crowded Capitol Rotunda taking selfies and patting each other on the back, I wonder if they even noticed the exquisite oil paintings on the wall by Trumbull depicting scenes before, during and after the Revolutionary War speaking to the fight for American independence against an expansionist monarchy. Sound familiar? I think they did not.

Art in our nation's Capital was born out of conflict. Rosa Parks in Statuary Hall; Maya Lin's Viet Nam Wall; the magnificent Lincoln Memorial & stunning MLK Statue. When visiting DC I am struck by the beauty of these symbols of our country. Beauty that was forged through dark times. As these monuments light up the DC night, they always give me hope. They will stand the test of time; their granite and marble strength will hold.

The oligarchs in power now will not stand. We will not let them. It is not who we are. We will protect the vulnerable and as FDR says: "provide enough for those who have too little." As Rena says: We are ready.

What a wonderful way to speak to these times through art, Alex. It is a way to reach for the sun in the darkest of days.

Expand full comment
Alexander Verbeek's avatar

Thank you, Sharon. See also what I just replied to Amanda Royal.

Expand full comment
Judith L Hubbard's avatar

Saving this post as best of all especially on this day of horror protested all over the world. In creativity we find light, courage to resist oligarchy and beauty to sustain us through all. Thank you for this! 😘

Expand full comment
Danièle Dugois's avatar

Everything is already so well said in these previous comments...

It’s an very interesting and so much sensitive reflection on art and its impact on our society and on each of us... Thanks much Alex !🙏

Art is intended to be lived together, to be shared in the community … Everyone can find in art lot of sources of deep reflection, of criticism, or wonder.

Appreciated or not, he never leaves indifferent. It causes reactions and can leave imperishable memories, because it often touches us deep inside us.

A quote that summarizes well, I think, the essential effect of art in our lives...:

« Taking into account the ideologies and upheavals specific to each era (either by representing or embodying them, or by reacting to them through criticism), art imposes itself as a key witness to the history of humanity, of which it delivers a great visual and sensory narrative. ”

Expand full comment
Alexander Verbeek's avatar

Thank you, Daniele. I'm rereading your quote and wonder what it means for those who are powerful and rich but for whom art has no significance in their lives. Historically, they will never be remembered for greatness; maybe for greed, military acomplisments, or for cruelty, but not for greatness. It can make or break the reputation of a dicator in the history books: I still have empire-style ornaments at home 200 years after the death of a dictator, but any art produced by the thousand-year-reich was crumbled and forgotten after 12 years. In the year 2225, no museum will display, and no individual will wear, a MAGA cap - the single cultural contribution of the present cult.

Expand full comment
Dr. med. Susanne Ruff-Dietrich's avatar

Loved this...

and it mirrors also my own feelings so well.

I tried to put them into words today also, here on substack.

Expand full comment
TCat's avatar

This article which links to today’s reminds me as well of all that we are distracted attention-wise by in this life …. and art as access to something even beyond …

Rick Rubin “it is not unusual for science to catch up to art eventually. nor is it unusual for art to catch up

with the spiritual”. Can we look beyond the canvas?

Expand full comment
John Summers's avatar

I am reminded (in a synesthetic way) of the orchestral works of Igor Stravinsky. A horrific majesty; exposed as ritualistic. Both Picasso and Van Gogh were iconoclasts; the former chain smoking Gitanes, and painting; the latter drinking absinthe, and painting. War! What is it good for? The early work of Picasso reveals his genius. (On a side note, so does the early work of Warhol). Happy saint Patrick's day. ☘️

Expand full comment
Alexander Verbeek's avatar

It’s a pity I can’t add photos here, I would have liked to share the bullfight painting he made when he was nine. It shows a mastery of painting that many mature painters can only dream of achieving someday.

Expand full comment
John Summers's avatar

𓃓

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jan 20Edited
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
Alexander Verbeek's avatar

Thank you, Lizzie

Expand full comment