The glacier collapse in India and the Paris Agreement
Looking back at this year: weeks 6 and 7 of 2021
 |
Yesterday, I shared photos of week 6 of this year, and I shared memories, but I didn't mention what happened in the world in the second week of February. One of the events that caught a lot of attention was the glacier collapse in India. I am sure you will remember the pictures of the water and rocks crashing through Northern Indian valleys, destroying houses, buildings, and many lives. But, in case you missed it, this is a short video from Al Jazeera news showing the devastation.
In the first days, there was a lot of speculation about the role of climate change in causing this event. In the weeks that followed, experts developed several theories about the possible cause. It seems now likely that climate change didn't directly cause the outburst; a landslide or a similar geological change event seems a more probable direct cause. However, environmental changes caused by climate change likely contributed to the geographic conditions that allowed for the disaster to happen.
The story of the environmental concerns in the area reads as one that we have read before in articles about other countries. The leading roles in these plots, from the Amazon to Flint, Michigan, are concerned scientists and local inhabitants on the one side and corporations and government on the other side that ignore their warnings until disaster strikes. Let me rephrase that last part: often until long after the disaster has struck.
A worldwide pattern, where the voices of scientists and the people are ignored
In this case in India, scientists warned for many years about the dangerously high rate of warming in the Himalayas. And the region's ecosystem had become too physically exposed to the dangers of development projects. Some scientists had advised against building dams in the higher river valleys. But the warnings were ignored, and more dams and highways were built.
It's a story that I see repeated all over the world by all kinds of governments. And, unfortunately, we also see it on a global scale; the story of climate change follows the same pattern. For decades, the voices of scientists and environmentalists were ignored while companies and governments pursued short-term successes that guaranteed more profits and reelections. They reaped the benefits of ignoring science at incredibly high long-term costs for others.
The U.S. is back on board
There was also positive news about the environment. In week 7, on 19 February this year, the historically biggest emitter of greenhouse gasses, the United States, officially rejoined the Paris Agreement. I believe we should all welcome that move but let's not forget that none of the nearly 200 other countries that joined this agreement had made the shameful step to leave the treaty.
So in the proper order of welcoming countries' policies, I would like to start by thanking all other countries for having emitted fewer greenhouse gasses in total than the United States. Second, I would like to thank nearly all other countries for still producing fewer emissions per capita than the United States, number 9 in the top 100 of CO2 emissions per capita (Qatar, Kuwait, and UAE occupy the top-3 positions). And third, I welcome the U.S. back in the league of countries willing to mitigate and adapt in line with the Paris Agreement.
After putting America's step into perspective, I would like to mention how much I welcome President Biden's priority to return to the treaty; he ordered this move on his first day in office. I am sure I wrote about it somewhere but couldn't find it. However, while looking for it, I found this article about Biden's climate policy challenges that I wrote this spring.
If you are not happy with the result of COP26 (like me), imagine how much less would have been achieved if his predecessor had won the elections. (In case this newsletter is more widely read in the U.S. than I expect: no, Biden didn't steal the election, if you believe so, stay tuned to The Planet, where we check our facts).
Meanwhile in Ottawa
So that was catching up with the weeks six and seven, and we are one day closer to the end of the year. I still see a few forgotten Halloween decorations, but increasingly, I see the Christmas decorations in the neighborhood. I also saw the first snow this week, and looking at the pictures of week seven of this year in mid-February, I realize that we will soon get much more than this first thin white layer in the mornings. So let's look at some of my pictures of week seven.
I enjoy walking in these snowy landscapes; somehow, the sounds of a forest are so different when there is a thick layer of snow. And, of course, the light is fantastic; the low sunlight is reflected on the white snow and filtered through the bare trees. I love all seasons; the Canadian winter is long but very special.
The pandemic kept Canadians inside. But a virus can't beat all traditions: like skating in Ottawa, with Parliament Hill in the background.
And Luna needed some rest after a busy day.
Please support this initiative by taking a subscription. Read about nature, the environment, history, travel, politics, Luna, and more. It is your support and encouragement that keeps me writing until late at night, and this production is not supported by any advertisements.
Notes:
https://www.cnn.com/2021/02/12/asia/india-glacier-raini-village-chipko-intl-hnk/index.html
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2021_Uttarakhand_flood
https://www.economicshelp.org/blog/10296/economics/top-co2-polluters-highest-per-capita/
Each time I see photos & videos of dramatic & devastating glacier collapses, it feels almost physically painful. As though we’ve lost a part of ourselves and, of course, we have. I recall this one very well. So sad. If individuals can feel these losses, how could COP26 leaders be so apathetic? It’s impossible to understand.
Likewise, the response from many in the US continues to be blasé, not only to climate devastation, but decency in general. Case in point, yesterday’s vote in the US House. With the exception of two, all Republican Representatives blithely overlooked one of their worst colleagues who displayed an imaginary murder of a Democratic Representative & an attack on the President. All characteristic of a tyrant who still holds them in his thrall and who imperiled the world by withdrawing from the Paris Agreement and promoted denial of climate change. Thankfully, he was defeated in the last election but his evilness is still a very real threat.
I’m grateful for you and your endless work to enlighten the masses at every opportunity of our bleak future if leaders & individuals don’t wake up and take immediate serious action.
Also thankful for your hopeful messages of wonderful photos that help appreciate the beauty we still have on this planet. And sweet Luna too.
Interesting timing of this newsletter and the event(s) mentioned. I spent the last two days in Zermatt. Apart from the Matterhorn (it's as stunning as it looks on pictures), there were a few things I noticed and have been noticing. So much concrete used very high up for dams, to control water coming down the mountain, new roads, just houses being built in the most random places and also, the railway tracks. As much as I liked the train ride - that also struck me. One of the things people in Switzerland seem to ignore is that it's not only our glaciers that are melting, it's also our Alps that are crumbling. Permafrost isn't holding the rock together the way it used to. I took some pictures of weird structures in the ice way up at 10,000 ft.
There's always several factors to such desasters, as you mentioned, but we really often wait "until long after the disaster has struck" to act.
Also glad the US is "back" - they should have never left.
I saw snow as well this week. It even snowed a little on Gornergrat yesterday. I look forward to many more of your snow pictures. Did you ice skate? Must be in your genes. Although, I'm Swiss and I don't really ski - forget I asked ;-).
As for Luna - a well deserved rest, I'm sure. She must have a very busy cat life. I love her little cat bed. And I'm amazed she actually uses it. I grew up with cats and they slept EVERYWHERE but never in their cat beds.